Dietary recommendations for older adults with heart failure: are they worth their salt?

scott-hummel-2Due to neurohormonal activation and often renal dysfunction, patients with heart failure (HF) are physiologically attuned to retain sodium and fluid. Since worsening symptoms in HF are typically due to fluid congestion, the conventional wisdom has been to reduce dietary salt intake. In observational studies, low sodium intake is associated with fewer hospitalizations for decompensated HF. However, restricting sodium also increases systemic neurohormonal activity, which could be detrimental particularly in patients with HF and reduced ejection fraction. While flawed and challenging to interpret, some randomized trials suggest that sodium restriction actually increases readmission and mortality risk!

What’s more, studies in hypertensive animal models as well as in humans with hypertension imply that the response to sodium is not inherently the same in all patients. “Salt-sensitive” people have greater increases than others in blood pressure, oxidative stress, and inflammation during high sodium intake that may contribute to the development and worsening of HF. This has traditionally been attributed to impaired renal sodium excretion. However, recent work suggests that some ingested sodium is not processed through the kidneys, but stored non-osmotically in the skin and other organs.  The purpose and cardiovascular effects of this storage are not yet known. We and others are studying the endothelial glycocalyx, a thin glycoprotein lining of blood vessels, as a possible link between sodium intake and vascular dysfunction.

With the increasing understanding that frailty, sarcopenia (diminished muscle mass), and metabolic disarray are common and contribute to poor prognosis in older patients with HF, a blanket recommendation to eat less salt could have other unintended consequences. In dietary surveys, older adults with HF who report eating a low-sodium diet frequently have calorie and micronutrient intake deficiencies that could directly contribute to weight loss and impaired mitochondrial function.

At this point, the only certainty is that further research is needed to define the appropriate diet for older patients with HF – and the answer may not be the same for everyone. Ongoing studies (SODIUM-HF; GOURMET-HF) will provide more information over the next few years. Until then, advice for older patients with HF to restrict salt intake is reasonable – provided careful attention is paid to volume management and diuretic dosing to avoid excessive neurohormonal activation. In my practice, I also recommend consultation with a dietitian to make sure that a well-intentioned focus on sodium doesn’t contribute to deficiencies in caloric or other nutrient intake.

By: Scott Hummel, MD